The Logic Forum Discussion Area

Logic
This Forum is Locked
Author
Comment
View Entire Thread
Re: Some P are Q

Hi Disgruntled.
Hang in there and finish the job!
If you want to reprove the professor and fellow students for their behavior you might want to read them our correspondence in class.
Alternatively, print it out and hand it out. At least to the professor. Maybe even to the faculty head.
Best, Avi.

P.S. By the way,the reason why the Talmud works that way is that it is essentially a conventional, rather deductive discourse. Probably your professor is so conventional minded that he actually thinks that way, i.e. with little inductive method. Hence his bad reaction to your intellectual independence.